Rishab Week 1: Speaking Middle Earth - How Invented Worlds Build Real Worlds

Written by: Rishab Thaker

Have you ever loved a hobby so much that you accidentally wrote one of the best-selling fantasy series of all time just to justify it?

I was reading this fascinating BBC article about J.R.R Tolkien and other writers, and it completely shifted

how I view The Lord of the Rings. Most people assume that Tolkien came up with

with his fantasy world first, and then invented the beautiful languages to make the elves and dwarves feel

authentic. It’s actually the opposite, as Tolkien was a linguist first. He invented elvish (specifically Quenya

and Sindarin) for fun, and then realized that his languages needed a world of people to speak them.

Tolkien's Elvish Script, Source: alejomiranda/Getty Images

This fits perfectly with our Q1 theme of “Language and Identity". For Tolkien’s characters, their language is their identity. The Elves speak flowing, melodic tongues that reflect their immortal, nature-bound existence. The Dwarves, on the other hand, speak Khuzdul, a harsh, secretive language that mirrors their tough, insulated, mountain-dwelling culture. You can’t separate who they are from how they speak.

Reading this made me think about how we construct our own identities through the words we choose. We may not be speaking Elvish in the hallways (although we totally should), but the slang we use, the tone we adopt with our friends versus our teachers, and even the memes we reference are all ways we signal who we are and what “tribe” we belong to. Tolkien just took that concept to his own, literal, mythological, extreme.

I am truly curious to know how you all think. Have you ever noticed yourself switching your “language”, or pattern of speech, to fit a certain identity? And be honest- has anyone here actually tried to learn High Valyrian or Elvish?


Comments

  1. Pranav PandeySeptember 2, 2026 at 2:39 PM

    Amazing Post! To answer your question, yes I do often switch the way I speak depending on who I am speaking with. With my friends and family I am always informal, but in public and professional environments I attempt to be as professional as possible. This blog post did an amazing job in proving how language can be a direct representation of your identity and pointing out the many different languages and styles spoken in different environments.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Miroua RaymondSeptember 2, 2026 at 8:34 PM

    Hi Rishab, your blog was very interesting! I really need to read or watch The Lord of the Rings, because everyone keeps referencing it. Still, your post was easy to understand because of the high quality of writing.

    I had no idea that Tolkien made multiple languages for his characters. I can’t imagine creating a whole new language from scratch. I'm already struggling enough with English. It’s also so cool that the languages reflect the personalities of the characters that speak them. That adds a whole new layer to the work.

    I like the connection you made between how the characters’ languages reflect their identities, and how we speak differently reflect our identities. I’ve definitely noticed a difference in how I speak to different people. Although, it’s mostly a difference in confidence between speaking to my grandparents in Malayalam and speaking to my friends in English, rather than trying to fit a certain identity.

    And while I definitely have no idea how to speak High Valyrian or Elvish, I’m so curious to know if you can? Because that would be very cool.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Riley Week 1: The Chinese I was Supposed to Speak

Image
I was eight years old when my father took me, my eleven-year-old sister, and our Caucasian mother to his hometown in Hong Kong , China. By that point, I had been admitted to a Mandarin Immersion Program for three years, speaking broken Chinese because unlike my classmates, I did not have family at home that could help me learn Mandarin . For context, Mandarin is the primary language spoken in China, but coastal communities such as Hong Kong and Guangdong mainly speak Cantonese , a different variant of Chinese. The entirety of my Asian family is from Hong Kong, so none of them were capable of helping me learn Mandarin. When my family arrived at the airport on mainland China for our connecting flight, my father got down on his knees, looked me and my sister in the eyes, and warned us that people in China “liked to kidnap mixed children”.  He continued to inform us that we would be our family's only method of communication until we arrived in Hong Kong, because my father did not under...
Read more

Ethan Week 1: Who is “Bro” – 8/26 [8:50pm]

Image
Anyone Gen Z and younger is bilingual. Not in the sense that they can speak in two languages, but in the sense that they could communicate perfectly using “Bro,” “LMAO,” “😭,” and a plethora of other convoluted abbreviations and ambiguous emojis. It shocks me that, at one point in history, language consisted of actual words that actually meant what they said. Now that the Internet has arrived, we have decided that the “💀” could mean anything from this sucks to a form of laughter. This trend doesn’t just occur in English; almost every other language has evolved into this digital jargon. However, this phenomenon reveals something much deeper than just a different form of communication.  Take a moment to read your last text message to your friend and compare that to the last conversation you had with that friend in real life. Most likely, you’ll realize that the way you communicated the same meaning may have been completely different, yet your friend understood it both ways. This mat...
Read more

Htin - Week 1 : The History I Hold onto

Image
    This year marks my 4th year living in the states. At the mention of my recently immigrated status, all and sundry seem to say the same thing: “Your English is so good, did you grow up bilingual?” And my answer to that always had and always will be, a proud “no”.                I grew up in Myanmar, a country with its rich history of cultural traditions and most importantly, language development. Myanmar was first founded as a unified state in the 11th century by King Anawrahta . It brought together a diverse range of ethnicities to stand proud as an independent nation. After centuries of marinating history, the countryside still paints itself in the shade of its emeralds it produces while the growing urban cities tower above the flying pigeons as they flock towards the pagodas’ feeding grounds. The Sanghas pace in an undeviating line, resembling that of a strand made from saffron colored fabric while the elementary student...
Read more